I asked the students to give me their best arguments in favor of eating meat, and these are the results.
I asked the students to give me their best arguments in favor of eating meat, and these are the results. I have also shown this list to others, and they have been unable either to support the arguments any better or to come up with another, better argument.
If anything, they have criticized these arguments for being invalid i. I wanted to object to all of the arguments that people presented just in case people might think they are good arguments. Therefore, we can eat meat. If one wants to take what the Bible says to support one's position, one will have to believe that a wife must submit to her husband, homosexuals are immoral, one must not eat cloven-hoofed animals, rebellious sons must be taken to the center of town and stoned to death, etc.
One cannot pick and choose between points in the Bible without being unfair and arbitrary. If there are any points or even one point in the Bible with which one does not agree, one has to be able to justify why that one point should not be accepted but that every other point should.
What that justification will amount to is to be some other argument for eating meat that is not in the Bible see the other arguments below, e. Because people do tend to pick and choose what parts of the Bible they like and dislike, it may show that people have their own ideas of right and wrong regardless of what the Bible says.
It also might show that most people think that the Bible is fallible. What is intended by "Man shall have dominion over the animals" paraphrased from Genesis 1: Maybe what is intended is not, "Do whatever you want to the animals, like torturing, eating, bestiality," etc.
See Objection 4 below. It would seem that parents would have dominion over their children; but this does not imply that we can torture and kill them in order to eat them, right? For anyone who does not believe that every word of the Bible is true, it is not convincing.
First, it would seem that God wants us to eat only vegetables: It is true that the Old Testament does have laws for meat-eating after this Genesis passage, but then we have an inconsistency to address.
With the exception of fish, peak meat consumption occurred in adults aged 20 through 49, particularly for red meat ( g/day), with lower intakes at younger and older ages (pmeat, poultry, total meat, and processed meat). Arguments for In-Vitro Meat Growing meat tissues in cell cultures would produce a number of desirable consequences: it would be a good source of protein, less fatty/more nutrient rich meat than conventionally raised animal products, less polluting, reduce fossil fuel and water consumption, eliminate food born disease, scale back on farmland currently used for feeding and raising animals. The United States, with less than 5 % of the global population, uses about a quarter of the world’s fossil fuel resources—burning up nearly 25 % of the coal, 26 % of the oil, and 27 % of the world’s natural gas.
Second, there are Biblical passages which actually say that we should care for animals: For example, we should help an ass get up if it falls down Exodus Also, in the LDS Doctrine and Covenants, it says, "Yea, flesh also of beasts and of the fowls of the air, I, the Lord, have ordained for the use of man with thanksgiving; nevertheless they are to be used sparingly; And it is pleasing unto me that they should not be used, only in times of winter, or of cold, or famine" Sect.
This text suggests that meat be eaten sparingly, but ONLY in winter, cold, or famine. This was written when there were no other options available, and certainly does not seem to apply to warm climates such as Arizona, California, etc.
See also Mylan Engel Jr. Our culture accepts eating meat as well. Therefore, I should be able to eat meat. The fact that one has been raised to eat meat is more of an explanation of why the meat-eating started, but cannot, by itself, justify the claim that eating meat is ethically good.
What if one were raised to hit people on the heads with hammers anytime the desire arose?Per Capita Meat "Consumption" (lbs/person) in the United States, The data below are from the USDA/Economic Research Service, timberdesignmag.com, Feb.
1, The per capita meat "consumption" is measured in lbs/year and reflects the total amount of meat supply in the United States adjusted for loss. May 15, · Red Meat vs Chicken: An Argument Against The False Distinction People often tell me that they've given up eating red meat out of concern for animals, the environment, or .
Vegetarianism- A Hidden Perspective Americans eat more meat per person in the world, and the world is suffering because of this. The truth is that many global problems, like hunger, or rainforest destruction can easily be solved if Americans cut down their meat consumption.
Jan 10, · Studies and reports suggest a variety of reasons for the decline in American meat consumption, The report treats consumers as victims of government bias against the meat industry. We’re eating less meat because we want to eat less meat.
As I decrease my medications, the urgency I feel around men and . In May, the Chinese government announced plans to cut its country’s meat consumption in half — partly for public health reasons, but also to reduce .
Vegetarianism Essay Examples. 33 total results. An Analysis of the Cause For Vegetarianism. words. 1 page. A Study on the Problems Cause by Vegetarianism. words. An Argument in Favor of the Decrease of Meat Consumption in the United States. 1, words. 3 pages.
An Introduction to the Reasons for Vegetarianism.